UK launches plan to ensure safety of journalists

UK launches plan to ensure safety of journalists

UK launches plan to ensure safety of journalists

The British government has published the UK’s first national action plan to protect journalists from abuse and harassment.

  • Plan sets out how journalists will be protected from threats of violence and intimidation
  • Includes new measures to research the problem and training for police forces and journalists
  • Broadcasters, publishers, social media companies, law enforcement, industry bodies, unions and the government all make pledges

It follows reports to the government from journalists who have suffered abuse and attacks while going about their work, including being punched, threatened with knives, forcibly detained and subjected to rape and death threats.

A survey of members of the National Union of Journalists in November also found more than half of respondents had experienced online abuse while nearly a quarter had been physically assaulted or attacked.

The plan will increase awareness of the safety challenges faced by journalists operating in the UK and introduce measures to tackle them in a joint effort by law enforcement, broadcasters, publishers, industry bodies, unions and the government.

Measures include new training for police officers as well as aspiring and existing journalists, and commitments from social media platforms and prosecution services to take tough action against abusers – including responding promptly to complaints of threats to journalists’ safety.

The plan has been endorsed by the National Committee for the Safety of Journalists, membership of which comprises industry stakeholders including the National Union of Journalists and Society of Editors.

It will be reviewed as necessary on an ongoing basis and supports the wider work the government is doing to uphold freedom of speech, in particular protecting journalistic content from censorship and takedown online. The Government is also publishing a broader update today on its ongoing work to tackle intimidation in public life.

Prime Minister Boris Johnson said:

“Freedom of speech and a free press are at the very core of our democracy, and journalists must be able to go about their work without being threatened.

“The cowardly attacks and abuse directed at reporters for simply doing their job cannot continue.

“This action plan is just the start of our work to protect those keeping the public informed, and defend those holding the government to account.”

Culture Secretary Oliver Dowden said:

“Attacks on journalists are not only horrendous for those individuals but an assault on our democracy. Today’s action plan will make sure journalists can go about their vital work without fear.

“But just as we protect the physical safety of journalists we must protect their freedom to write and report too. Tackling worrying trends on online censorship of journalistic content and controversial views, we will ensure our forthcoming online safety laws build in robust protections for journalism.”

Minister for Media and Data and Chair of the National Committee for the Safety of Journalists, John Whittingdale (pictured above), said:

“We will not tolerate a world where journalists are silenced through fear or censorship and want the UK to set an international example for the respect, treatment and protection of those working in the field. This plan is the first step towards achieving those aims.”

The plan sets out a series of commitments from relevant organisations focused on protecting the safety of journalists based in the UK.

The government

The Department for Digital, Media, Culture and Sport (DCMS) and the Home Office will shortly issue a call for evidence to build a better understanding of the volume and type of threats and abuse against journalists. It will build on existing reports from journalists – for example, of hospital admissions following assaults and online death threats – to develop a targeted approach to tackling the issue.

The Foreign, Commonwealth and Development Office (FCDO) will use its global network, including its co-chairship of the Media Freedom Coalition, to share insights and strategies on the protection of journalists, with the aim of strengthening approaches in other countries.

Online platforms

With online abuse being one of the biggest challenges facing journalists today, particularly for BAME and female journalists, Facebook and Twitter have committed to respond promptly to complaints of threats to journalists’ safety.

The government is already tackling online abuse through the forthcoming Online Safety Bill. All social media users, including journalists, will be better able to report abuse and be supported by the platforms if they do so.

Online platforms will be required to protect users and enforce their terms and conditions or face sanctions – including fines of up to 10 per cent of their annual turnover or having their services blocked. The Bill will also enshrine in law protections for journalistic content and free debate online.

Police

The National Council for the Training of Journalists (NCTJ) will work with the police which will provide training for journalists reporting on police operations, initially through a workshop at the University of Portsmouth.

The police will engage with the National Union of Journalists (NUJ), the Society of Editors and others to update their training offer for police around journalists covering demonstrations and investigating crime against journalists.

Every police force is to be given access to a designated journalist safety liaison officer while the National Police Chiefs’ Council has appointed a lead officer – Chief Constable Gavin Stephens – to take responsibility for crime against journalists at national level.

Media organisations

Organisations such as the Media Lawyers Association will produce further guidance to help journalists recognise and understand when abuse breaks the law and what they can do about it. The NCTJ will provide safety training for student journalists while the NUJ and Society of Editors will collate and host a free online support pack for journalists.

Publishers and broadcasters have committed to providing new training for staff and freelancers on managing threats. They will review and collaborate on safety policies and ensure they are well publicised, and establish designated safety officers within their organisations.

Prosecution services

Freedom of expression and the right to receive and impart information are recognised and protected by law. Criminal offences committed against journalists exercising those rights jeopardise both the right to free speech and public service, and prosecutors rightly take such offences extremely seriously.

In the plan, the separate UK prosecution services for England and Wales, Northern Ireland and Scotland reaffirm their commitment to taking a robust approach to crimes against journalists and bringing those responsible to justice.

Ian Murray, executive director of the Society of Editors said:

“The Action Plan recognises the urgency of protecting journalists carrying out their vital role in protecting democracy.

“Due to their role in holding the powerful and those in authority to task journalists attract strong reactions. But this should not manifest itself in ways that threaten journalists and their families. This action plan makes that clear.”

NUJ general secretary Michelle Stanistreet said:

“Attacks on journalists are designed to silence and intimidate those who work to uphold the public’s right to know. NUJ members have shared horrific experiences of being attacked, abused and threatened – on and offline – simply for doing their job.

“It’s clear that reported incidents are the tip of the iceberg and that harassment and abuse has become normalised. This action plan, with its range of practical measures and protections, is an important step towards changing that and ensuring journalists can get on with their vital work free from harassment or intimidation.”

News Media Association chief executive David Newell said:

“The coronavirus crisis has thrown a spotlight on the importance of trusted news and information yet abuse of journalists, often on social media, has risen markedly over the same period.

“There can be no place in our democratic society for abuse and attacks on journalists, which constitute a threat to free speech, and the national action plan is a welcome development to help address this.”

Chair of the National Police Chiefs’ Council’s Communications Advisory Group, Chief Constable Gavin Stephens said:

“Journalists are a vital cog in a functioning society and deserve to be respected for the role they play in providing a public information service and holding authorities to account.

“Any restriction of those values severely impacts public confidence and trust both of which are core principles in policing and what drive the communities we serve to be safe and feel safe.

“I’m committed to raising awareness within policing of the long term damaging impact that targeting journalists can have and will be doing so through my new role. The impact of these crimes is not just on individuals and their welfare but also on press freedom itself, which has to be upheld and protected.”

INSI issues coronavirus advisory

INSI issues coronavirus advisory

INSI issues coronavirus advisory

The coronavirus is spreading around the world and is now present in 77 countries and on all continents except Antarctica. As the situation is constantly evolving please ensure you keep up to date with the health authorities’ advice in your own country.

INSI members are cancelling/carefully considering unnecessary travel to protect staff, preparing home working strategies and drawing up contingency plans if major events like the Olympics should go ahead, all while dealing with staff fears and a news agenda almost entirely driven by the fight against the virus. 

Background

Months into the outbreak, health authorities still have limited knowledge of how the virus works and exactly how it is spread. Covid-19 has an estimated average fatality rate of around 1%. In practice that percentage is believed to be lower in young and healthy individuals, but higher in people over 60 and people with underlying conditions, according to the UK Chief Medical Officer.

To put the figure in context, SARS, another coronavirus, had a much higher mortality rate of around 10% but its symptoms were very easily identified and its spread was very limited. Around 8,096 people were affected during the 2002-2003 SARS outbreak and 774 died.

By contrast Covid-19 spreads much more easily from person to person and symptoms can often be mild, making it difficult to identify potential spreaders.

There are also significant differences between Covid-19 and the seasonal flu.

With an estimated average mortality rate of 0.1%, seasonal flu is 10 times less lethal than Covid-19. Most importantly, a vast majority of the population is already immune, or at least partially immune, to seasonal strains of the flu. Vaccine and anti-viral drugs are available for the regular flu.

As Covid-19 is an entirely new virus, there is no immunity at all in the population, no vaccine and no drugs as yet, meaning that an unprecedented number of people may require hospitalisation, putting a great strain on the health system of any country.

Symptoms

The symptoms are fever, a dry cough and shortness of breath. Most people start showing symptoms three to five days after infection, but the maximum incubation period isn’t fully confirmed.

Fever is not always present at the onset and, reportedly, 40% of people who were admitted to hospital in China with Covid-19 did not have a raised temperature. Temperature screening is therefore not a useful tool to detect whether someone is infected, who might be sick, or who might still be capable of spreading the virus.

People in the same risk groups as flu are still thought to be the most affected. That includes people with existing medical conditions, including respiratory problems, but also those with diabetes, heart disease, kidney disease, the immuno-suppressed and, possibly, even pregnant women.

However, not all those who have died were older or had pre-existing conditions.

There have been no known cases of severe infection in anyone who is healthy and under the age of 20.

Transmission

Coronavirus is a respiratory virus and is present in secretions from the nose, throat, mouth and lungs. These secretions are exhaled, coughed, or sneezed out then inhaled. They can also contaminate any kind of mucosal surface such as the eyes, nose and mouth. Some of the larger droplets fall and contaminate surfaces. Tinier droplets can be inhaled and very tiny droplets will actually dry out and become like dust particles. They can remain suspended in the air for a period of time and be inhaled deep into the lungs. These dried out droplets can remain active for hours, or even days, though exactly how long is unknown.

With SARS, another coronavirus, victims only passed on the illness after showing symptoms, which meant that by isolating them the outbreak was brought under control. Diseases like measles, however, are harder to control because the virus can be spread without people knowing that they’re sick. This coronavirus may fall into this category, although this is not confirmed.

The easiest way to control the spread of the virus is by thoroughly and repeatedly washing your hands with soap for at least 20 seconds. If you are in an environment that is contaminated with virus particles, your hands must be clean before coming into contact with your face, nose or mouth. This is a key hygiene precaution that will limit the spread of the virus. Avoid shaking hands.

Scientists estimate that each person who is infected can spread the infection to an average of 2.5 new people.

Tests/treatment

At the time of writing, only government-authorised facilities are able to test for Covid-19. No effective anti-viral drugs have yet been identified but trials are underway.

Masks and goggles

Except in specific circumstances, face masks are not recommended for the general public, as they have not been shown to be protective in any measurable way in studies on the spread of flu viruses. Wearing a mask in wide open spaces, or generally outdoors, is also not useful. 

There are however cases when masks can or should be worn. There are two main kinds of masks:

* Surgical masks: these are the masks most often being worn by members of the public, particularly in Asia where they were common even before the outbreak. They don’t offer protection to the wearer but are instead designed to protect others from sneezes, coughs or simple exhalation. Surgeons use them to avoid contaminating their patients. A surgical mask could be given to someone who is known to be infected or has a cough, cold or the flu in order to protect those around them. Look for a CE mark to show that it meets certain standards of fluid resistance. Fashion masks being sold over the counter with designs on them are unlikely to offer adequate protection.

* High filtration masks: the so-called N95 (in the US) or FFP masks (in the UK and Europe) are used in a medical environment for personal protection. N95 masks are designed to protect against 95% of particles of a 0.3 micron size (the average particle in cigarette smoke, for example, is 0.3 microns in diameter). The equivalent European standard is FFP2 and FFP3 which filters out 94% and 99% respectively. Masks must fit tightly. If air is getting in around the edges the mask will not work. Beards, for example, interfere with the contact between the mask and the edges of the skin. A high-filtration mask with a valve allows you to breathe out and to wear the mask for longer and be more comfortable but removes any protection for others.

If wearing a mask make sure not to touch the outer surface, contaminate your hands and then transfer the contamination back to yourself. In a contaminated environment like a hospital, put on and remove your mask only and exclusively by the straps and wash your hands every time you touch it. Most people don’t do this, making the use of a mask pointless.

Ordinary glasses or sunglasses provide a degree of  protection from a cough or sneeze, making goggles unnecessary, except for those in a high-risk environment.

Contrary to common belief, the majority of modern, large airplanes are actually remarkably clean because of HEPA filtration and air conditioning systems which destroy viruses, even down to the size of coronaviruses. It is advisable to turn on the air vent above your head so the air can push any suspended particle to the ground faster.

Self-isolation

Self-isolation is different from quarantine. Anyone who tests positive for Covid-19 or has been in close contact with someone known to be infected by the virus will be kept isolated in quarantine.

Self isolation is a discretionary preventative measure that applies to people who have a higher chance of having been exposed to the virus. Individual government recommendations vary by country and are being regularly updated. Staff returning from assignments – or holidays – in countries where the coronavirus is more widespread and serious such as China, Italy or Iran are strongly recommended to self-isolate.

That means staying at home for 14 days, not using public transport and not doing anything that might expose others to the risk of infection. As much as possible, people in self isolation should keep to a separate room in the house, or at least  stay two metres away from family members. They should also avoid sharing food or toilet facilities or be the last one to use them before disinfecting.

Viruses are destroyed by detergents, alcohol, extreme drying and heat, so these are all good ways to de-contaminate, especially clothing.

Newsroom safety/working from home

News managers at organisations with offices, staff and freelancers around the world are struggling with conflicting advice from health authorities in different locations, while at the same time covering a story for which there is a huge appetite.

Different governments have different recommendations or regulations about what to do in case a member of staff tests positive for Covid-19. At the time of writing, the UK and other countries’ regulations do not require, nor recommend, closing down an office or sending staff home. However, some members tell INSI they have taken, or plan to take, a much more conservative and cautious approach by asking staff to work from home if at all possible should an employee come down with Covid-19.

However, it is widely agreed that anyone who has any flu-like symptoms (coughs, cold, sneezes) should categorically stay at home. This might be a culture change in some organisations but no one should be going into their work place with germ-ridden hands or runny noses. Employers must keep people with cold or flu symptoms out of the workplace to avoid spreading the virus and the anxiety associated with possible contagion

Organisations should get prepared for large numbers of staff working from home, ensuring they have extra personal laptops and access to VPNs, for example.

For those in the newsroom, public areas, including hot desks, must be thoroughly cleaned with an anti-bacterial cloth or spray. That includes door handles, toilets, shared facilities like kitchens and computer keyboards and mice.

Employees should be vaccinated against flu. The vaccine does not protect against coronavirus but avoiding ordinary flu is a good way of reducing unnecessary anxiety, alarming co-workers or ending up isolated or quarantined for a preventable reason.

Many news organisations are reconsidering foreign deployments entirely and cancelling all non-essential travel. INSI members say this is made slightly easier by a lack of interest in stories other than the coronavirus which is dominating the news agenda.

Plans to manage staff safety at the Euro 2020 football championships, which are scheduled to take place all over Europe this summer, and the Olympics in Japan are still being developed, assuming these events go ahead.

Managing staff abroad

It is essential to get prepared. Make sure local staff know where to go for medical treatment should they get sick. In countries where medical facilities are poor decide whether a trip to the hospital for oxygen, for example, is the best approach, or whether evacuation would be preferable. Reach out to hospitals or public health authorities in advance rather than waiting for something to happen. Have a plan in place at an early stage so you are prepared if staff are infected. Take account of any staff members with a pre-existing condition that could put them at greater risk.

Interviewing recovered patients

People can continue producing the virus for at least 14-16 days after the onset of symptoms. Avoid interviewing or getting close to anybody within that period of time.

Sources: Dr Richard Dawood, the Fleet Street Clinic; UK government; INSI members

Image by AFP via INSI

Tunisia – safety advisory from INSI

The International News Safety Institute urges journalists to exercise caution while covering demonstrations in Tunisia.

There have been reports of unrest since the murder of the liberal politician Chokri Belaid
last week, the first political assassination since Tunisia’s independence from France in
1965.

On 8 February Tunis was engulfed by violent protests, which have not occurred since January 2011. Police fired tear gas into the crowds and there were reports of armed youths smashing cars and clashing with police. Although the situation has stabilised it is likely that protests will begin again this Friday (15 February).

INSI’s advice on covering demonstrations and other civil disorders includes:

Journalists should be aware that water cannons and tear gas (CS gas) may be used.

Journalists have also reported that their mobile phones and cameras were stolen while
covering last Friday’s protests. Consider covering the unrest with your back to a wall to
ensure that this is less likely to happen.

Covering demonstrations and other civil disorders

Before you head out, consider the following:

• Ensure your accreditation is in order and easily accessible.

• You may wish to alert the authorities that your news organisation plans to cover the
protests, if it is appropriate and not dangerous to do so in the country you are in. If so,
obtain the mobile number of the person in charge; the more senior the better.

• Take protective gear. This can include helmets, gas masks, or bullet proof vests with
protective plates. Your decision regarding this may depend on what weapons the local
police force uses for crowd control.

• In case of tear gas, carry a bandana and soak it in water. Cover your mouth and nose
with it. Try to use some sort of goggles to protect your eyes. Ladies – consider not wearing
make up as tear gas sticks to it.

• Try not to wear contact lenses as the tear gas will get under the lense. Bring eye drops
and spare glasses.

• Wear comfortable boots that you can run in.

• Wear natural fabrics, which may be less flammable than synthetic fabrics.

• Prepare a backpack with supplies to last a day: lightweight rain gear, energy bars and
water, spare batteries for electronic equipment, protective equipment.

• Pack a medical kit and know how to use it.

• Carry a photocopy of your press accreditation and telephone numbers of your editor and
lawyer. Make sure your editor knows how to reach your family in case you’re arrested or
hurt.

• Set your mobile phone to speed dial with an emergency number pre-set.

• If possible, ensure you have studied the map prior to going on the ground. Consider
filming from high vantage points. Agree a rendez-vous point in case you lose your team
and agree a “safe” place where you can retreat if the situation becomes too dangerous.

On the ground:

• Try not go alone and if you can, take someone to watch your back if you’re shooting
pictures.

• As soon as you arrive, look for escape routes and ensure you know the landmarks to
head for if you become disorientated.

• Try to stay on the edge of the crowd and do not get caught on the line between police
and protestors.

• Crowds have a life of their own. Be constantly aware of the mood and attitude.

• Alert your editors if the mood starts to change and begin to think of what your plan is.

• If planning to change direction, seek advice from people who have just come from the
direction you’re heading.

• Television crews should travel as light as possible. If experiencing aggression, ensure
your backpack is big enough to hold the tripod and pack it away. Be prepared to leave it
behind if you need to run away.

When trouble erupts:

• Avoid horses. They bite and kick.

• Try to stay upwind from tear gas.

•  Try to avoid getting in the line of the water being fired as it will damage your kit. It often
has dye in it for the security forces to be able to identify the protestors after.

• If the police detain you, try to ask them to call the person in charge if you have their
number. Try to speak to a senior officer, as this will have more impact.

• Call your editor, ensure legal advice is available through your organisaiton.

• Try to avoid violence if you can and move away to film if necessary.

Safety advice for media working in Nigeria

The International News Safety Institute urges journalists and media workers to exercise extreme caution while operating in some areas of Nigeria.

Violence in northern Nigeria has escalated in the past two years. There is a high threat of terrorism and attacks are indiscriminate.

Curfews are being enforced across Nigeria, including Plateau, Kaduna and Yobe States and Kano City, Kogi Central Senatorial District and Mubi town in Adamawa State. Curfews are regularly used following incidents of unrest and can be imposed and lifted at short notice. Journalists and media workers will have to comply with these curfews, which can be monitored via local media outlets, if not risk arrest.

International news events have triggered anti-Western demonstrations, and Western diplomatic missions, interests and citizens could be the focus for protests. INSI encourages journalists to exercise caution while covering protests. News events may also present some opportunities for terrorist groups to exploit.

Demonstrations have occurred in a number of cities across northern Nigeria as well as Abuja.

Be vigilant while operating around government, security and educational institutions and international organisations as well as public venues such as restaurants, bars, markets, hotels, shopping centres, places of worship and areas frequented by expatriates, foreign tourists and business travellers.

INSI advises journalists to maintain a low profile, vary routines, and not set regular patterns of movement while travelling. A number of attacks have taken place on public or religious holidays, and there have been regular attacks on churches in northern Nigeria at times of worship.

There is also a threat of kidnapping throughout Nigeria and foreign nationals have been the target of kidnaps. On 20 December 2012 a French national was kidnapped by armed men in Katsina state in northern Nigeria. On 12 May 2011 a British and an Italian national were kidnapped in Kebbi State. Both hostages were killed in Sokoto on 8 March 2012.

The Islamist sect Boko Haram (“Western Education/Values are Forbidden) has admitted to being behind a number of attacks against churches and other establishments since 2009. More than 600 people were killed last year on attacks blamed on it, while human rights groups say that the sect has killed more than 3,000 people since 2010. While Boko Haram has carried out many attacks, it is also clear that some of the attacks have been carried out by bandits with no links to Boko Haram. When no responsibility is taken, the violence is often discovered to be politically motivated rather than religiously driven.

INSI advises against travel for international journalists to the following areas:

Borno State
Yobe State
Riverine areas of Delta, Bayelsa, Rivers, Akwa Ibom and Cross River States
Warri city
Kano city

Should it be vital to go there, a robust security plan must be in place, to prevent problems during the story.

INSI also urges journalists to exercise extreme caution while travelling in:

Bauchi State
Jos city
Riyom and Barkin Ladi Local Government Areas in Plateau State
Gombe State
Mubi Town in Adamawa State and the area north of Mubi Town that borders Borno State
Non-riverine areas of Delta, Bayelsa, Rivers and Akwa Ibom States
Abia State
Kaduna City
Zaria City

If you need any further information on working in Nigeria please contact INSI – Hannah Storm (+44 7766 814274; email: hannah.storm@newssafety.org)